Manchester City: Are Enzo Maresca’s team’s problems psychological or tactical?

Manchester City manager Enzo Maresca has the international break to fix the growing problems in his squad, after three consecutive Premier League defeats have dropped the club six points behind league leaders Arsenal.

The Italian made a dream start after taking over from Pep Guardiola in the summer, guiding the club to a record seven consecutive victories at the start of the season. Since then, City have lost three in a row. In September, the club were found guilty of breaking the Premier League’s financial rules, and matches have continued while they await the outcome of their appeal. With possible sanctions hanging over them, is City’s recent league form down to psychological issues, or are there tactical problems Maresca needs to address?

The psychological impact

Renowned sports psychologist Dr Paul McCarthy, who has 25 years’ experience working with top clubs in England, Scotland, Germany and France, works with players on both their personal and professional lives. He says both affect how they perform on the pitch, and that staff often need to “piece together a jigsaw” when situations become disrupted.

“Players are like everyone else. They talk about what is going on in their own lives and things that are topical, especially about uncertain events,” McCarthy said. “It generates communication with a lot of stories and rumour, and over time, if there are enough losses, there often becomes a reduced collective efficacy.”

He explained that collective efficacy is a squad’s belief in its ability to win, and that a run of defeats can shake that belief, even when a team has enjoyed success in the past.

City were sitting pretty at the top of the table after their flawless start, but have since dropped to third, behind Arsenal and Brighton. After the guilty verdict was announced during the last international break, Maresca’s men won their first game back, beating 10-man Liverpool at Anfield, then narrowly overcame Ipswich at the Etihad Stadium. They have since lost to Aston Villa, Brighton and Nottingham Forest, with defensive issues exposed and individual mistakes proving costly.

City did not concede a single goal from individual errors in their first seven league games of the season. That has changed dramatically in the past three matches, in which four mistakes from players have contributed to goals. They have conceded 13 goals in 10 league games, their highest total at this stage of a season since 2008-09, when they had let in 16.

Asked whether uncertainty over the appeal might affect players’ focus, McCarthy replied: “Yeah, that would be a very reasonable human response. When people are uncertain about their future, that uncertainty leads to a lack of perceived control, so uncertainty is often more stressful than bad news, and the research shows that.”

He added: “While you are waiting and you don’t know the outcome, you are uncertain of where you are, and there is that lack of control for a lot of people. They come to training, they play their games, and it’s outside of their responsibility.”

The tactical questions

At Chelsea, Maresca explained in a video for NBC Sports how he moved counters into a 3-2-2-3 shape before pushing one player forward to create a 3-1-6 shape. He said using six attackers was a tactic he had used against Inter Milan to outnumber their back five. This season, he has adopted the 3-1-6 shape more permanently, swapping a second holding midfielder for an extra attacking midfielder.

A team full of quality footballers has good reason to play in a front-foot, imposing manner, but the success of any tactic depends on the skills of the players asked to carry it out. The biggest questions concern Elliot Anderson and his midfield partners. Anderson, who cost more than £100m in the summer along with Enzo Fernandez, is naturally a roaming midfielder and relies on his physical strengths. At Nottingham Forest, he defended intensely, pressed high and wide, and contributed to attacks. This season, Maresca and his staff have tried to mould him into a more sitting midfielder following the departure of Rodri in the summer. Learning that role will take time, as it did for Rodri when he first joined.

Coaching a player into a key role is not a problem in itself, but City have looked exposed through the middle of the pitch more often in recent games. Anderson, who has largely impressed, keeps falling back on his habits, stepping out of his holding position to press or track opponents and win the ball back. Clever opponents have exploited this by dragging him out of position and then finding players in the space he has vacated. Enzo Le Fee, for example, recognised Anderson’s willingness to track him and pulled wide, and with Anderson leaving the central area, Brian Brobbey was able to drop in and receive the ball directly from his centre-back.

With City pressing high and often man-to-man, Anderson has had to cover more ground, while the midfielders alongside him lack the physicality needed to support him. In possession, Fernandez, often one of City’s midfield three, makes frequent attacking runs into the final third. When this happens, City can be left with as few as two or three players behind the ball, which gives opponents good conditions to counter-attack if they break the first press.

For Maresca, the issue is less about the shape and more about losing the ball in the first place. After the defeat to Forest, he said: “You concede transitions when you lose the ball, and when you don’t win duels.”

Concerns at the back and in build-up

The skill set of the players behind Anderson raises further concerns. Gianluigi Donnarumma is not a goalkeeper renowned for his ball-playing ability. The defenders are serviceable on the ball but have made costly errors under pressure when playing out from the back this season too.

Guardiola tackled similar issues last season by asking midfielders to take on more responsibility in build-up play. The departures of Rodri and especially Bernardo Silva, who would drop deep and take City from their own goal into midfield alone, have made those problems more obvious. Anderson is a very good player, but he cannot single-handedly resolve build-up play in the way Bernardo Silva did. Ayyoub Bouaddi may be someone who could be used in that role, as he showed against Brazil’s press at the World Cup.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *