Leeds 1-0 Tottenham: Spurs to lodge complaint with Pro Ref, but was Bogle deserving of a red card?

Tottenham are preparing to lodge a formal complaint over the decision not to send off Jayden Bogle for his challenge on Mathys Tel during their defeat at Leeds. Bogle, 26, escaped any punishment despite catching the Spurs forward on the back of the ankle with his studs in the first half of Saturday’s game.

It is understood Tottenham believe Bogle should have been sent off. They will write to the refereeing body Pro Ref to seek an explanation as to why the incident did not result in a dismissal.

The Video Assistant Referee (VAR) reviewed the challenge thoroughly, but referee John Brooks was not sent to the pitchside monitor, so Bogle stayed on the pitch. Former Premier League assistant referee Darren Cann said the Leeds defender was “fortunate” not to be dismissed.

“Bogle’s challenge meets the criteria for serious foul play as he endangers the safety of an opponent,” Cann said. “He can consider himself lucky to still be on the pitch.”

Tottenham lose their momentum

When play resumed, fewer than nine minutes of the first half remained, and Tottenham’s momentum and composure were fading quickly. Roberto De Zerbi‘s side never appeared to recover from the incident and, after the break, were outworked and outplayed by the home side.

Nevertheless, the Italian, perhaps buoyed by his side’s recent rise up the table, refused to blame the referee’s decision for Spurs’ failings.

“We deserved to lose the game in the second half and didn’t play like we can,” he told TNT Sports. “It’s a journey for us because we can learn from this game.

“I am sorry for the performance in the second half. We didn’t play like a top team. We didn’t have the right character and physicality in the second half.”

“We have full confidence in the referee and VAR”

When the public address system at Elland Road confirmed a VAR check was in progress, it seemed only a matter of time before Bogle would be shown a red card. The Leeds defender had been full-blooded in his pursuit of the ball, and he seemed certain to follow Jean-Philippe Mateta, the Crystal Palace forward who was sent off for a similar challenge against Spurs the previous weekend.

Strangely, Brooks never made his way to the pitchside monitor to review the incident. The entire four-minute review was therefore conducted solely by those in the VAR hub at Stockley Park.

“They’ve said no red card, and this will create debate,” former Tottenham midfielder Michael Brown told radio listeners.

Because Brooks had not initially cautioned Bogle, the defender escaped without any punishment.

“I have big confidence in the referee. Nothing changes if he goes to the monitor,” De Zerbi said. “If they didn’t take the right decision I don’t know. We have to keep the eyes on the performance where we can improve.”

Early in the second half, Tottenham’s frustration, seemingly stemming from the decision not to dismiss Bogle, came to a head. Defender Pedro Porro and De Zerbi himself were booked simultaneously following a challenge by the Spanish defender.

De Zerbi described the decision to caution Porro as “incredible” after what had transpired in the first half.

“I was surprised on the yellow card for Pedro Porro because it was clear,” the Italian said on a post-match programme. “The potential red card, I couldn’t say.

“We have full confidence in the referee and VAR. I cannot say nothing more.”

Was Bogle fortunate to escape a red card?

Bogle was certainly very lucky to escape even a booking. The foul happened in strange circumstances. He was positioning his body to challenge Tel with his right foot, and in trying to plant his left foot, he stood on the ankle of the Spurs player.

At full speed, it looked innocuous, which is probably why Brooks chose not to show a card after giving the foul. Once the slow-motion replays were examined, however, the nature of the contact on Tel appeared very ugly, with a twist of the ankle.

The incident could easily have led the VAR, Tony Harrington, to send Brooks to the pitchside monitor for an on-field review for a red card. Harrington spent far too long looking at the replays, probably feeling he had more time while Tel received treatment. Longer reviews, however, tend only to cause doubts about process.

Harrington eventually told Brooks: “I’m confirming the on-field decision of no red card. There’s a lack of speed going into the challenge and he’s stepping into the tackle. Confirming a reckless challenge.”

A reckless challenge is a yellow card, but the VAR cannot intervene and advise that Bogle should be booked. Harrington’s phrase “stepping into the challenge” is also important. It does not mean a player cannot be sent off, but such challenges naturally involve less force, so they are far less likely to prompt a VAR review for a red card.

How does it compare with Mateta’s red card?

There is an argument that Mateta, who was booked on the field, made less forceful contact on the ankle of Micky van de Ven. Yet the nature of the challenge is crucially different. Mateta made a lunging, stretching tackle with studs leading, the kind generally considered to carry a higher degree of force and potential danger to the opponent.

That said, even though Bogle was not really making a challenge, the nature of the contact means many may feel a VAR review for a red card should have taken place.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *