
Brighton fans were calling for Fabian Hurzeler to be sacked in February, yet a subtle change in approach has the Seagulls among the Premier League title contenders, and they sit second heading into the international break.
Graham Potter set the tone. Roberto De Zerbi raised expectations. Fabian Hurzeler is blowing both out of the water.
There was scepticism when the German arrived at the Amex in 2024 as the youngest permanent head coach in the English top flight. Nearly two and a half years on, that scepticism looks rather silly.
In October, Paul Merson said that if Brighton could beat Liverpool at Anfield and Manchester City at the Etihad, Hurzeler’s side would truly be in the title race. They lost on Merseyside, but they stunned City with a 1-0 victory. A 50 per cent return from those two trips is more than respectable, and had they stayed in the hunt through Christmas, Brighton would have to be viewed as genuine championship contenders.
It is an remarkable statement, especially considering where Hurzeler found himself earlier this year.
An eight-game winless run through January and February heaped pressure on the German and saw him booed by the Amex faithful at times. “It’s the hardest moment [of my career] but it’s also the moment where I learn the most and I will grow the most,” Hurzeler said after a 1-0 defeat at home to Crystal Palace in the midst of that torrid streak.
Learn and grow he most certainly did. But in what way has that been the case?
A change in style
When he first arrived, former Liverpool midfielder James Milner likened Hurzeler to Jürgen Klopp. This season, though, his Brighton side have adopted less of a ‘heavy-metal’ style.
Their distance covered per game is similar to last term, but their intensity appears to be down, with far fewer sprints on average. That does not mean Brighton have become lazy. Instead, they are picking and choosing their moments, setting traps rather than flying around the pitch. The result is a far more efficient performance out of possession. Their interception figures are roughly unchanged from last season, at 8.4 per game compared with 8.3, and they are forcing more high turnovers.
That efficiency has allowed Brighton to see much more of the ball. Only Arsenal, Manchester City and Tottenham have a higher possession percentage in the Premier League. Their build-up play is also far less direct and transitional, with the Seagulls managing more than three extra 10+ passing sequences per game than last season.
They are by no means playing tiki-taka football, but they are trying to set the tempo on the ball rather than off it.
The change affects both ends of the pitch. Brighton are already three clean sheets away from matching their Premier League total from last season. They have close to four more shots a game and average slightly over one extra goal.
Revenge served cold
If more evidence were needed of how the change has worked wonders for Hurzeler, look at how Brighton fared when they last faced Crystal Palace. Just 252 days after “the hardest moment” of his career, Hurzeler exacted revenge with a 5-0 thrashing of the Eagles.
He has also had fans pleading for him to stay after being linked with the Manchester United job. Going from hearing his own supporters sing ‘sacked in the morning’ to that is quite some turnaround.
Maturing with experience
Hurzeler was only 31 when he was appointed, so his ideas and tactics were always going to mature over time. Admittedly, 33 is far from old, but those two years have given the Texas-born coach considerably more wisdom to draw on.
With that wisdom, his side now have a new-found sense of control. It has raised the club’s stock, and it has raised their coach’s stock too.
Over the last 12 to 18 months especially, the idea that work done off the ball matters more to success than what is done on it has moved to the forefront of everyone’s mind. The famous counter to that is that the best form of defence is attack.
Hurzeler appears to have found a happy medium between those two ideologies. His players still adopt a modern high press, but they now focus on locking things down defensively by patrolling games on the ball.
The balance is working perfectly. Whether it can be sustained to produce something truly remarkable is anyone’s guess, but that should not stop Brighton fans from daring to entertain a little delusion of grandeur. Europe? The Champions League? A Premier League title? The further up you go, the less realistic it feels to say. Yet, from adversity, Hurzeler has Brighton playing in a way that makes it hard to rule them out of the running for any of it.
Brighton next face Hull City, with kick-off at 2pm on Super Sunday.